What Does Effective Volunteer Management Look Like?

effective volunteer leadership

In an effort to help Live Intentionally readers reach their dreams and inspire others, I’ve invited you to share your dreams. Every Friday I’ll feature another reader & their dream. Today’s post is by Ed Cyzewski…

My friend was burned first. She had been a faithful nursery volunteer at our church for years, but after giving birth to her second child, she had her hands full and was trying to back off as she entered a new season of her life.

The phone calls continued every week: someone cancelled and they needed her in the nursery.

She eventually left the nursery ministry altogether. Soon we were watching slide shows on Sunday morning of the poor children we’d abandoned.

Not too long after that, I was put in charge of a worship team. I liked the idea of leading worship, but I was in over my head as a manager of a team. To make things worse, I was the face of the youth movement in our church as we switched from hymns to contemporary songs.

I didn’t succeed. I had my good Sundays, but eventually I was asked to step aside.

That did it.

While some volunteers in the churches I’ve attended have received good training and support for their ministries, I found that many more have stories similar to my own and to my friend’s. Too many volunteers were burned out from factors such as misguided recruitment, poor training, minimal support, and lack of appreciation.

Oddly enough, certain ministries in our church were very well managed, but volunteers in many other ministries were burning out and falling through the cracks. How can we ensure volunteers are empowered to serve in the areas where they are passionate, trained, supported, and appreciated?

It has been a dream of mine to figure this out and to help other volunteers.

Since then I took an independent study course in seminary on volunteers, conducted a study of a church’s volunteer culture, and worked as a volunteer coordinator in the nonprofit world—working with around 200 volunteers. I learned that managing volunteers effectively isn’t too difficult, but it does require personal attention, planning, and a degree of flexibility.

However, the problem is that many pastors tend to be big-picture thinkers, lacking in the administrative, nuts and bolts approach that makes an effective volunteer manager. In addition, even if some pastors are strong managers, our seminaries aren’t teaching them how to manage volunteers. Either way, our pastors aren’t learning the basic skills required to recruit, train, and appreciate volunteers.

My next step in helping volunteers and leaders take positive steps forward in service involves teaching a course on managing volunteers for the long haul this summer at Biblical Theological Seminary outside of Philadelphia, PA. It’s my dream that future and current pastors will learn the basic skills they themselves need or that need to be cultivated on their staff.

It’s one thing to “equip” Christians with biblical truth. However, any time we work together on a ministry team, whether we’re serving food to the homeless or leading worship on Sunday, we need to learn the basic principles of volunteerism and ensure our volunteers will last for the long haul.

Now I’m opening this up to you:

What do you want to know about recruiting and managing volunteers?

If you took a weekend-long course on church volunteer management, what would you expect to learn?

About edcyzewski

Ed Cyzewski (MDiv Biblical Theological Seminary) works as a freelance writer in Eastern Connecticut. He is the author of Coffeehouse Theology: Reflecting on God in Everyday Life, an introduction to contextual theology as well as the Coffeehouse Theology Bible Study Guide and a Coffeehouse Theology Discussion Guide. Ed writes regularly for a number of magazines and web sites. He blogs on freelance writing at: www.edcyz.com and on theology at www.inamirrordimly.com.

6 Responses to “What Does Effective Volunteer Management Look Like?”

  1. Great topic Paul,

    I have been fortunate to be able to volunteer most of my life and I have seen both sides of the volunteer management coin. A few things I have observed:

    – Volunteers are employees. They just aren’t paid. Volunteers deserve the same respect paid employees do.
    – Like paid employees, volunteers want/need to be part of the solution. They may be the best source of “out of the box” thinking an organization can get free. Ask their opinion. Brainstorming sessions work well with volunteers.
    – They are not being paid, so it is even more important to remember to recognize and reward them. A sincere “Thank you” goes a long way.
    – Learn their name and something else about them. Really? They are working for you free.
    – If I am consistently working my 40-hour employees 60 hours a week, I am understaffed. The same is true with volunteers. If they can give 4, but I always ask for 6, I am not managing head count well and I need to go recruit more volunteers.
    – Rotate your volunteers. Give them a chance to try something else. How cool is it to be able to try something and fail without fear of losing your “paying” job.
    – Reward them with training; leadership, interpersonal skills, software, finance, delegation, time management, priority setting. They become stronger volunteers for you and you give something back to them.

    Lastly, I work for my volunteers; they do not work for “my cause” or me. My job is to do everything possible to make their volunteer experience safe, productive, effective, rewarding, and meaningful. If I do this consistently, I won’t have too much trouble being understaffed.

  2. I think 2 of the biggest factors in successfully leading volunteers are vision and relationships.

    People volunteer when they’ve caught a vision for how their service can make a difference in the lives of the people they’re serving. It’s important to cast a clear and compelling vision when recruiting, and because “vision leaks” it’s important to constantly recast the vision reminding everyone why we’re doing what we’re doing.

    Relationships can make or break a team. If there’s conflict on a team or people just don’t know each other, volunteering can become a grind. But when you serve with people you know and like, it can make serving in even the most difficult circumstances fun. So, leaders of volunteers need to build relationships with their volunteers and need to make team building a priority.

  3. Pete, great points! I’ll have to quote your comment in my course, as you’ve said a lot very succinctly.

    Paul, if we do botch things up with our volunteers, a strong relational foundation certainly can help us along the way of restoration and healing.


  1. Tweets that mention What Does Effective Volunteer Management Look Like? | Live Intentionally -- Topsy.com - February 4, 2011

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by OurChurch (dot) Com, edcyzewski. edcyzewski said: RT @OurChurchDotCom: @edcyzewski shares his dream of helping leaders lead volunteers effectively: http://bit.ly/eza83y. […]

  2. Tell the Story of Your Big Dream in a Guest Blog Post | Live Intentionally - March 18, 2011

    […] Ed Cyzewski – What Does Effective Volunteer Management Look Like? […]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.